Skip to main content

'I Think That's A Fair Question To Ask': John Kennedy Speaks To Ketanji Brown Jackson

sen. kennedy
Facebook/JohnNeelyKennedy

At yesterday's Senate Judiciary Committee confirmation hearing of Judge Ketanji Brown Jackson to the Supreme Court, Senator John Kennedy (Republican-LA) spoke about the "appropriate role" of the federal judiciary, calling for federal judges not to make law. His remarks were also reported on his official website.

Sen. Kennedy speaks to Ketanji Brown and said: Congratulations. In addition to honors the wonderful state of Minnesota, and unless you correct me, I am going to assume that your purple attire is also meant to honor LSU and my state.  I want to compliment you and the Biden White House for selecting senator Doug Jones to advise you. Senator Jones knows the senate and the senate knows senator Jones. And we know him to be quite the intellect. 

Talking about the Good judgment and the United States Supreme Court, Kennedy said:

But more importantly, we know him to be a person of good judgment and goodwill. And I am glad that you have been listening to him. I hope we will be able to use this hearing today to talk about, if not implicitly at least implicitly, 2 things. 

The first is the legitimacy of the United States supreme court. Where does the court get its legitimacy? What can we do to enhance it? Judicial legitimacy is important. I don't need to tell you that I'm rather fond of the constitution. I know you are, too. When members of the US supreme court interpret it, I want the American people to believe them. 

I may not agree but the men and women who made that decision are intellectually honest and people of good faith. One of the primary roles of the US supreme court is to uphold the rule of law. And sometimes justices have to uphold the rule of law when it's not popular. Sometimes justices have to uphold the rule of law when it's not popular with the majority of Americans. 

After this Sen. Kennedy talks about the bill of rights, he said:

And I am rather fond of the bill of rights, too. I know you are as well. I have never believed that the bill of rights was there for the high school quarterback or the prom queen. They are covered by it. But the bill of rights is there to protect the rights of people who don't see the world exactly like everybody else. Or who don't look exactly like everybody else. Now, unfortunately, through history, we have had people, some well-unmentioned who tried to delegitimize the supreme court. 

Then, Kennedy mention the US Presidents, he said:

We had a president way back when who tried to impeach a supreme court justice. We had another president who wanted to pack the supreme court. And most of the people who want to delegitimize the supreme court believe that the -- unlike our founders, in my judgment, believe that members of the supreme court ought to be and are politicians in robes. They believe that the American supreme court ought to be a mini congress. They believe that the law is not the law. The law is supposed to just be politics, practiced in a different way. They believe in court-packing. And they are wrong. 

Number 2, I hope today that we can use this as an opportunity to talk about, if not explicitly at least implicitly. That is what I am going to try to do, the appropriate balance between representative government and declarative government. Now, in representative government, as you well know, people, through their elected representatives make policy. And in declarative government, the policy is made by the administrative state and the federal judiciary. Now, both are important. I'm not saying that this is a zero-sum game or either-or. 

Kennedy also spoke about the "appropriate role" of the federal judiciary, calling for federal judges not to make law. In his remarks he said:

But what's just as important is we have the appropriate balance between representative government and what I will call declarative government. I mean, we have an administrative state. Did any of us ever think it would get this big? Is that healthy? We need to ask ourselves that. Is it really healthy to arrive at a circumstance where the administrative state passes thirty-five laws a year to our one? Is it really healthy to have an administrative state that makes its own laws and interprets its own laws and enforces its own laws before courts with respect to which the administrative state appoints the judges? I think that's a fair question to ask. 

These are the few paragraphs of Sen. Kenndy's remarks, you can watch the complete video shown below:

Comments

Amazon

Popular posts from this blog

'This Is The Most Extraordinary Thing I Have Ever Seen': Hawley, Biden Nom Have Unbelievable Clash

  Photo credit: Gage Skidmore/CC BY-SA 2.0,  via Flickr At today's Senate Homeland Security Committee hearing, Sen. Josh Hawley (R-MO) clashed with Colleen Shogan, nominee to be Archivist of the United States, and National Archives and Records Administration. On February 28, 2023, Senator Josh Hawley (R-MO) clashed with Colleen Shogan, nominee to be Archivist of the United States and National Archives and Records Administration, at a Senate Homeland Security Committee hearing. The heated exchange centered around Shogan's past public statements on social media and her refusal to provide a full accounting of her public posts. During the hearing, Hawley questioned Shogan about her previous statements on Twitter, which he characterized as "pretty grossly partisan and...offensive." He asked her to provide a full accounting of her public posts on Twitter, to which Shogan responded that her personal Twitter account consisted of posts about her mystery novels, events at the W

'Why Would We Subsidize Non-US Citizens?': Governor DeSantis Defends Ending Tuition Help For Undocumented

  Photo credit: Gage Skidmore/CC BY-SA 2.0,  via Flickr Gov. Ron DeSantis (R-FL) defends prohibiting undocumented immigrants from getting out-of-state tuition waivers. Governor Ron DeSantis of Florida has been defending his decision to prohibit undocumented immigrants from receiving out-of-state tuition waivers in Florida's colleges and universities. This policy change has sparked controversy and criticism, with many arguing that it is discriminatory and could limit educational opportunities for undocumented students. In response to a reporter's question about the policy change, Governor DeSantis cited his administration's efforts to make higher education more affordable for Floridians. He noted that Florida has the most affordable higher education in the country, with in-state tuition averaging around $6,000 to $6,200. He also expressed his opposition to raising tuition, which he believes could undermine the affordability of higher education in the state. However, the gove

'This Is Just Sort Of An Insult': Rand Paul Questions Biden Archivist Nominee Colleen Shogan

Photo credit: Gage Skidmore/CC BY-SA 2.0,  via Flickr At today's Senate Homeland Security Committee hearing, Sen. Rand Paul (R-KY) questioned Colleen Shogan, nominee to be Archivist of the United States about classifications. During the Senate Homeland Security Committee hearing, Senator Rand Paul questioned Colleen Shogan, nominee to be Archivist of the United States, about her understanding of the Archivist's role in certifying amendments to the Constitution and whether the Archivist has the power to change or alter the election results.  Shogan stated that the Archivist's function is ministerial and that the Archivist publishes an amendment when it becomes part of the Constitution but does not decide whether an amendment has been ratified. She also stated that she would not allow security at the Archives to force people to cover clothing that has a political speech on it. Senator Paul expressed his concern about the over-classification of government documents, citing an

President Trump Erupts On 'Woke Left' And 'Radical Left Communists,' Unveils Proposed ESG Ban

  Photo "Donald Trump" by  Dan Scavino In a video posted social media, former President Trump pledged to ban ESG investing by executive order should he retake the presidency, slamming the "woke left" and calling such investing a "threat" from "radical left Communists." Former President Trump has pledged to ban ESG (Environmental, Social, and Governance) investing by executive order if he retakes the presidency, in a video posted on social media. Trump slammed the "woke left" and called ESG investing a "threat" from "radical left Communists." In the video, Trump claimed that he issued a historic rule banning Wall Street and employers from investing retirement accounts in ESG for political reasons. He called such investments "poorly performing woke Financial scams" that would never be funded on their own merits. Trump alleged that the entire ESG scheme is designed to funnel retirement money to the "Mani

Rep. Jim Jordan Issues New Ultimatum To Biden And Washington Democrats in Yuma, Arizona

  Photo credit: Gage Skidmore/CC BY-SA 2.0,  via Flickr At Thursday's House Judiciary Committee field hearing in Yuma, Arizona, Rep. Jim Jordan (R-OH) spoke to witnesses about the situation at the border, and said that Republicans will have to use government funding to stop the flow of migrants. Representative Jim Jordan of Ohio has been making headlines for his remarks during a House Judiciary Committee field hearing in Yuma, Arizona. The hearing was focused on the situation at the southern border, and Jordan spoke passionately about the need to address the chaos and danger that he sees there. Jordan began his remarks by noting that President Biden had promised on his first day in office to dismantle many of the policies and structures put in place by the previous administration to secure the border. Jordan argued that this had led directly to the situation at the border today, which he described as "open border chaos." He then asked a question that he felt was fundament