Skip to main content

'Do You Believe Illegal Immigrants Should Be Allowed To Vote?': Lindsey Graham Presses Jackson

lindsey graham
Photo credit: Gage Skidmore/CC BY-SA 2.0, via Flickr

At the Senate Judiciary Committee confirmation hearing for Judge Ketanji Brown Jackson's Supreme Court nomination, Senator Lindsey Graham (R-South Carolina) asked Jackson about immigration policies. You can also read the conversation below this video.

Sen. Graham: Do you believe illegal immigrants should be allowed to vote, judge Jackson? 

Judge Jackson: Thank you, senator. Under our laws, you have to be a citizen of the united states in order to vote. 

Sen. Graham: So the answer would be no? 

Judge Jackson: It's not consistent with our laws so the answer is no. 

Sen. Graham: Why do they do that in new york? 

Judge Jackson: Senator, I'm not aware of the circumstances. 

Sen. Lindsey Graham: Good answer. The answer is no. Can an unborn child feel pain 20 weeks in the birthing process?

Judge Jackson: Senator, I don't know. 

Sen. Lindsey Graham: Are you aware anesthesia is a time period if there is an operation to save the baby's life because they can in fact feel pain. 

Judge Jackson: I'm not aware of that. 

Sen. Graham: That may come before you one day so keep an open mind. That's the only thing I ask you to do. You said just a bit ago that you apply the law and the facts and call them as you see them; is that right? 

Judge Jackson: that is correct, senator. 

Sen. Graham: You look at the statute as the way it's written and you try to apply it in its plain meaning; is that correct?  

Judge Jackson: that is correct, senator. 

Sen. Graham: Have you heard of a case called to make the road vs. Mclean? 

Judge Jackson: Make the road in new york, yes. 

Sen. Graham: make the road in new york, who are they?

Judge Jackson: Make the road new york is a nonprofit that represents various individuals in the sort of immigration law field. 

Sen. Graham: Right they are a nonprofit advisors advocacy group. Did you know they receive large donations from the Arabella network and George Soros open society network? 

Judge Jackson: no. 

Sen. Graham: Well, they did. Now, in that case, what was the issue?

Judge Jackson: the issue, in that case, was a challenge to a change in administration policy concerning expedited removal, which is a policy that congress enacted. In order to expedite certain removals in the immigration system. Ordinarily, before expedited removal.

Sen. Graham: Asylum cases do not fall in this category, right? 

Judge Jackson: well. 

Sen. Graham: Trust me on that because the statute says it doesn't. 

Judge Jackson: if a person who could otherwise be subject to expedited removal makes and has a credible fear of torture in their country they can be.

Sen. Graham: Can they make that claim?

Judge Jackson: They can be determined to qualify for regular removal rather than expedited removal.

Sen. Graham: so expedited removal is a creature of Congress, folks. And if you have been here two years or less, the statute -- the statute would allow the administration in office to have expedited removal avoiding a lot of the hurdles that would exist otherwise for people here two years or less. So, in the Obama -- even bush years, they did not look at it in terms of applying it to everybody. Some people coming by air got expedited removal, others didn't. 

The Trump administration decided to use the authority given to it by Congress to remove all eligible cases two years or less under the expedited removal statute. Is that a fair summary? 

Judge Jackson: Well, senator, I would say it differently. 

Sen. Graham: Well, say it differently. 

Judge Jackson: The statute that you put up indicates that Congress is giving the department. It says the attorney general but now it's the department. 

Sen. Graham: Right.

Judge Jackson: The ability to determine what category of aliens.

Sen. Graham: two years or less. 

Judge Jackson: yeah, but, importantly, the authority was -- it was not congress saying two years or less. What congress said is your agency has the authority to determine what category of persons between -- who have been here between zero and 24 months. 

Sen. Graham: which is two years.

Judge Jackson: no, forgive me, senator, what I'm trying to explain is that the authority given to the agency was to determine what length of time. 

Sen. Graham: They had the impression to make that.

Judge Jackson: What length of time? It was not the authority to deport everyone who has been here for 24 months. It was the authority to determine what length of time a person has to be here in order to be subjected to expedited removal. 

Sen. Graham: Here's what the statute says. The attorney general, which is actually the a.G. Secretary. May apply one and two of this subparagraph to any and all aliens described in subclass two designated by the attorney general, actually DHS. Now, I have been in this business for quite a while. 

What the Trump administration did was to use the discretion given to it by statute in a way different than prior administrations. This advocacy group, the Arabella-supported advocacy group tried to strike it down. You rule for them. Here's what the D.C. Circuit said about your ruling.

 There could hardly be a more definitive expression of congressional intent to leave the decision about the scope of expanded removal within statute or bounds to the secretary's independent judgment. The forceful phrase "Sole and unreviewable discretion" by its exceptional terms. Such designation shall be in the sole and unreviewable discretion of the attorney general and may be modified at any time. To those of us in the law writing businesses, I don't know how you could tell a judge more clearly that the administration, the agency in question has the discretion to do certain things within the statute. So this is an example, to me and you may not agree, where the plain language of the statute was completely wiped out by you. 

You reached a conclusion because you disagreed with the Trump administration and the D.C. Circuit of appeals said, as I have quoted just a minute ago, there could hardly be a more definitive expression of congressional intent to leave the decision about the scope of expedited removal within the statute or bounds to the secretary's independent judgment. 

You can watch the complete interaction in the video shown in this article above. 



Popular posts from this blog

The Obama rally crowd size hit the maximum venue capacity at Schenley Plaza in Pittsburgh, PA.

  John Fetterman & Barack Obama's Rally at Schenley Plaza in Pittsburgh today How many people attended Barack Obama's rally in Pittsburgh? A massive crowd of thousands of supporters turned up in Pittsburgh to listen to Barack Obama's campaign speech with John Fetterman, Gisele Fetterman, and Jaime Harrison in the closing days of the US Senate race.  A news reporter shared via Twitter that there was a massive line stretching from Bigelow to Craig streets for the Fetterman rally with Obama at Schenley Plaza in Pittsburgh. He also shares some photos and videos, which you can see below this article. Obama said at a Pittsburgh rally: "Whether it’s out of malice or ignorance, we’ve seen recently big celebrities re-posting vile anti-semitic conspiracy theories online." "And you don’t have to be a student of history to understand how dangerous that is and how unacceptable it is." Obama also highlights crime in red America,  something few Democrats want to do

AOC And Elon Musk Spar With Each Other On Social Media

Photo credit: nrkbeta/CC BY-SA 2.0,  via Flickr In a video released on social media Wednesday, Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-NY) fired at Elon Musk after she claimed her Twitter notifications were not working.  In an Instagram story posted on Wednesday, Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez claimed that her Twitter notifications were no longer working after she criticized Elon Musk. The criticism was over Musk's plan to charge users $8 a month to verify their accounts. Musk posted a tweet yesterday with a photo of a sweatshirt sold on the New York Democrats' website for 58 dollars. AOC fired back, saying that her workers are in a union and make a living wage, and proceeds go to, quote, "community investments" like tutoring kids. Ocasio-Cortez delighted in the fact that Musk lashed out at her, saying, quote, "We have a billionaire." That's the American dream right there. In her released video, AOC said: I was at a community event in the Bronx

WATCH: Biden Gaffes Again, While Speaking In Florida Rally

  Photo credit: Gage Skidmore/CC BY-SA 2.0,  via Flickr President Biden gaffes about the "war in Iraq" causing inflation while speaking in Florida, then blames his reference to Iraq on his son Beau dying there; Beau Biden died in Walter Reed years after his service in Iraq. President Joe Biden misspoke again at a rally in South Florida on Tuesday. During his remarks, President Joe Biden accidentally said that inflation was caused by quoting the war in Iraq. The president then corrected himself and said it was Ukraine, but I didn't study was quote thinking of Iraq because that's where my son died. Biden's son Beau Biden served in Iraq from 2008 to 2009.  Biden has previously claimed that Beau died in Iraq despite the fact that he died at Walter Reed many years following his service. Biden has said he believes exposures to burn pitoxins may have contributed to the cancer that claimed beau's life. He said: “They talk about inflation… inflation is a worldwide

Trump Mocks DeSantis During Pennsylvania Rally: 'Ron DeSanctimonious'

Photo "Donald Trump" by  Dan Scavino Former US President Donald Trump mocked Ron DeSantis as "Ron DeSanctimonious" at a Latrobe rally yesterday in Pennsylvania. Watch out for his complete reaction below. Trump, while addressing his rally, said these lines: Today I have the highest poll numbers I've ever had, perhaps partly because the Democrats are so severely running our country and people want our tremendous success of no inflation, energy independence, and military victory (remember, I defeated ISIS one hundred percent). Remember Al-Baghdadi and so many other things, including crime? We had it weighed down. But we have the best poll numbers; where are they putting them up on the screen? I think you should put them up and look at them. We are winning big, big, big in the Republican Party for the nomination like nobody's ever seen before. Let's say there is Trump at 71, Ron DeSanctimonious at 10 percent, and Mike Pence at seven. Targeting forme

DeSantis Issues Warning To Doctors Performing Gender Affirming Surgery On Minors

  Photo credit: Gage Skidmore/CC BY-SA 2.0,  via Flickr At a campaign event yesterday, Gov. Ron DeSantis (R-FL) slammed doctors who perform gender confirmation surgeries on minors. Florida Governor Ron DeSantis continued his campaign for re-election on Wednesday, focusing on cultural and war issues. DeSantis has doubled down on his controversial stance on gender-affirming care for minors; he decried the teaching of so-called gender theory in public schools. A topic that has earned him accusations of transphobia and bigotry by many LGBTQ Americans and their allies DeSantis has celebrated his state's commitment to take doctors' medical licenses if they performed gender-firming surgeries on minors as well. The issue has become a hot topic among Republican politicians, who believe it can help them win votes among parents wary of social change. This sentence is currently leading his Democratic challenger Charlie Crist by double digits. DeSantis mentioned in his speech that: