Skip to main content

'Do You Believe Illegal Immigrants Should Be Allowed To Vote?': Lindsey Graham Presses Jackson

lindsey graham
Photo credit: Gage Skidmore/CC BY-SA 2.0, via Flickr

At the Senate Judiciary Committee confirmation hearing for Judge Ketanji Brown Jackson's Supreme Court nomination, Senator Lindsey Graham (R-South Carolina) asked Jackson about immigration policies. You can also read the conversation below this video.




Sen. Graham: Do you believe illegal immigrants should be allowed to vote, judge Jackson? 

Judge Jackson: Thank you, senator. Under our laws, you have to be a citizen of the united states in order to vote. 

Sen. Graham: So the answer would be no? 

Judge Jackson: It's not consistent with our laws so the answer is no. 

Sen. Graham: Why do they do that in new york? 

Judge Jackson: Senator, I'm not aware of the circumstances. 

Sen. Lindsey Graham: Good answer. The answer is no. Can an unborn child feel pain 20 weeks in the birthing process?

Judge Jackson: Senator, I don't know. 

Sen. Lindsey Graham: Are you aware anesthesia is a time period if there is an operation to save the baby's life because they can in fact feel pain. 

Judge Jackson: I'm not aware of that. 

Sen. Graham: That may come before you one day so keep an open mind. That's the only thing I ask you to do. You said just a bit ago that you apply the law and the facts and call them as you see them; is that right? 

Judge Jackson: that is correct, senator. 

Sen. Graham: You look at the statute as the way it's written and you try to apply it in its plain meaning; is that correct?  

Judge Jackson: that is correct, senator. 

Sen. Graham: Have you heard of a case called to make the road vs. Mclean? 

Judge Jackson: Make the road in new york, yes. 

Sen. Graham: make the road in new york, who are they?

Judge Jackson: Make the road new york is a nonprofit that represents various individuals in the sort of immigration law field. 

Sen. Graham: Right they are a nonprofit advisors advocacy group. Did you know they receive large donations from the Arabella network and George Soros open society network? 

Judge Jackson: no. 

Sen. Graham: Well, they did. Now, in that case, what was the issue?

Judge Jackson: the issue, in that case, was a challenge to a change in administration policy concerning expedited removal, which is a policy that congress enacted. In order to expedite certain removals in the immigration system. Ordinarily, before expedited removal.

Sen. Graham: Asylum cases do not fall in this category, right? 

Judge Jackson: well. 

Sen. Graham: Trust me on that because the statute says it doesn't. 

Judge Jackson: if a person who could otherwise be subject to expedited removal makes and has a credible fear of torture in their country they can be.

Sen. Graham: Can they make that claim?

Judge Jackson: They can be determined to qualify for regular removal rather than expedited removal.

Sen. Graham: so expedited removal is a creature of Congress, folks. And if you have been here two years or less, the statute -- the statute would allow the administration in office to have expedited removal avoiding a lot of the hurdles that would exist otherwise for people here two years or less. So, in the Obama -- even bush years, they did not look at it in terms of applying it to everybody. Some people coming by air got expedited removal, others didn't. 

The Trump administration decided to use the authority given to it by Congress to remove all eligible cases two years or less under the expedited removal statute. Is that a fair summary? 

Judge Jackson: Well, senator, I would say it differently. 

Sen. Graham: Well, say it differently. 

Judge Jackson: The statute that you put up indicates that Congress is giving the department. It says the attorney general but now it's the department. 

Sen. Graham: Right.

Judge Jackson: The ability to determine what category of aliens.

Sen. Graham: two years or less. 

Judge Jackson: yeah, but, importantly, the authority was -- it was not congress saying two years or less. What congress said is your agency has the authority to determine what category of persons between -- who have been here between zero and 24 months. 

Sen. Graham: which is two years.

Judge Jackson: no, forgive me, senator, what I'm trying to explain is that the authority given to the agency was to determine what length of time. 

Sen. Graham: They had the impression to make that.

Judge Jackson: What length of time? It was not the authority to deport everyone who has been here for 24 months. It was the authority to determine what length of time a person has to be here in order to be subjected to expedited removal. 

Sen. Graham: Here's what the statute says. The attorney general, which is actually the a.G. Secretary. May apply one and two of this subparagraph to any and all aliens described in subclass two designated by the attorney general, actually DHS. Now, I have been in this business for quite a while. 

What the Trump administration did was to use the discretion given to it by statute in a way different than prior administrations. This advocacy group, the Arabella-supported advocacy group tried to strike it down. You rule for them. Here's what the D.C. Circuit said about your ruling.

 There could hardly be a more definitive expression of congressional intent to leave the decision about the scope of expanded removal within statute or bounds to the secretary's independent judgment. The forceful phrase "Sole and unreviewable discretion" by its exceptional terms. Such designation shall be in the sole and unreviewable discretion of the attorney general and may be modified at any time. To those of us in the law writing businesses, I don't know how you could tell a judge more clearly that the administration, the agency in question has the discretion to do certain things within the statute. So this is an example, to me and you may not agree, where the plain language of the statute was completely wiped out by you. 

You reached a conclusion because you disagreed with the Trump administration and the D.C. Circuit of appeals said, as I have quoted just a minute ago, there could hardly be a more definitive expression of congressional intent to leave the decision about the scope of expedited removal within the statute or bounds to the secretary's independent judgment. 

You can watch the complete interaction in the video shown in this article above. 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Asthma Is One Of The 'Leading Causes Of School Absenteeism': AOC at a House Oversight Hearing

  Photo credit: nrkbeta/CC BY-SA 2.0,  via Flickr Addressing Asthma-Related School Absenteeism: AOC Advocates for Environmental and Economic Solutions at House Oversight Hearing In a recent House Oversight Hearing, Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (AOC) passionately addressed the issue of school absenteeism and its connection to childhood asthma. The transcript of her speech sheds light on the disparities faced by students, particularly in districts with environmental and economic challenges. Introduction: AOC began by challenging the common narrative surrounding school absenteeism, emphasizing that it's not merely a matter of choice or attitude but is often rooted in health-related issues. She highlighted one of the leading causes of absenteeism: asthma. The Impact of Asthma: Representing the Bronx, AOC drew attention to the high childhood asthma rates in her district. For many children, the school environment provides a haven from economic challenges and offers a source of

Senator John Fetterman Has Blunt Message For Pro-Palestinian Protesters Demanding Gaza Ceasefire

  Photo credit: Governor Tom Wolf/CC BY-SA 2.0,  via Flickr Sen. John Fetterman Advocates for Action: A Blunt Message on Gaza Ceasefire Protesters In a press briefing alongside the families of Israeli citizens held hostage by Hamas, Senator John Fetterman (D-PA) delivered a direct and uncompromising message to pro-ceasefire protesters. Fetterman expressed his frustration at the prolonged conflict and questioned the motivations behind demands for a ceasefire without addressing the root causes of the conflict. Opening with his interactions with victim groups, Fetterman highlighted meeting with six families affected by the ongoing crisis. He emphasized that the suffering should have ended long ago, raising a fundamental question for those advocating a ceasefire: why aren't they demanding the immediate return of all hostages and insisting on Hamas's surrender? Fetterman challenged protesters to consider the consequences of not addressing both aspects of the conflict simultaneously.

'This Is Not War—This Is Slaughter': AOC Demands Gaza Ceasefire, Slams Israeli PM Netanyahu

  Photo credit: nrkbeta/CC BY-SA 2.0,  via Flickr In a powerful address on the House floor, Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-NY) passionately criticized Israel's military actions in its conflict with Hamas. The congresswoman expressed deep concern over the extensive human toll the conflict has taken, describing it as a massacre rather than a conventional war. AOC began her statement by acknowledging the chair and addressing the alarming number of casualties on both sides. She stated that over 1,200 Israelis had lost their lives, and 136 remained hostage as of October 7th. Notably, she emphasized that 27,485 Gazans, including women and children, were affected, facing challenges in accessing fully functional hospitals. "This is not war; this is slaughter," AOC declared, condemning the level of destruction and devastation in the region. Despite the significant loss of life, she criticized the Netanyahu government for falling short of its stated objective of destroy

'We Are Winning': AOC Praises The Green New Deal And The Push To Fight Climate Change

  Photo credit: nrkbeta/CC BY-SA 2.0,  via Flickr "We Are Winning': AOC Celebrates 5 Years of the Green New Deal, Highlights Progress, and Charts the Future in Democratic Press Briefing" At a recent Democratic press briefing, Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-NY) passionately spoke about the Green New Deal, praising its impact on climate policy and job creation. In her address, she reflected on the journey of the Green New Deal over the past five years, debunking initial criticisms and emphasizing the strides made in addressing the climate crisis. The Birth of a Vision: Representative Ocasio-Cortez began by acknowledging the inception of the Green New Deal, a visionary 10-year plan for social and ecological transformation aimed at saving the planet. The three core principles outlined were to accelerate decarbonization, create millions of jobs, and ensure no community is left behind in the transformation. Facing Early Criticisms: The Green New Deal faced immediate

Anna Paulina Luna Asks If Hillary Clinton Or Stacey Abrams Should Be Charged With 'Insurrection'

Photo credit: Gage Skidmore/CC BY-SA 2.0,  via Flickr Unveiling Alleged Election Lies: Rep. Anna Paulina Luna Questions Charges of 'Insurrection' Against Hillary Clinton and Stacey Abrams At a recent House Republican press briefing focused on a resolution declaring that former President Trump did not engage in an insurrection, Representative Anna Paulina Luna (R-FL) took the opportunity to call out Democrats who she claims questioned the validity of election results. Luna's remarks centered on the alleged suppression of information and manipulation by social media platforms, particularly in relation to the events surrounding January 6th. During the briefing, Luna expressed her concern about the government's ability to find terrorists in caves in the Middle East but seemingly failing to apprehend those responsible for planting a pipe bomb on January 6th. She pointed to a hearing at the Oversight Committee where Twitter was questioned, suggesting that the Department of Ho

Governor DeSantis Defends Calls To Only Fly U.S. Or Florida Flags On Public Buildings

  Photo credit: Gage Skidmore/CC BY-SA 2.0,  via Flickr DeSantis Upholds Tradition: Defending Calls to Exclusively Fly U.S. or Florida Flags on Public Buildings In a recent statement, Governor Ron DeSantis of Florida defended his stance on advocating for public buildings to fly only the U.S. or Florida flags, highlighting his belief in the importance of maintaining a clear and unambiguous display of national and state pride. Governor DeSantis began by acknowledging that he hadn't personally witnessed the controversy but addressed the broader concept. He articulated his position, stating that choosing to fly the American flag and the State of Florida flag exclusively does not target any particular group. Instead, it reflects a decision not to engage in the practice of displaying various flags on public buildings. "It's not targeting anybody; it's basically saying that we're not going to get into this business of doing this. I think that's totally fine," Gov

NJ Gov. Phil Murphy Signs Executive Order To Establish A New Jersey-India Commission

Photo credit: Phil Murphy/CC BY-SA 2.0,  via Flickr TRENTON - NJ Governor Phil Murphy Strengthens Ties with India: Signs Executive Order Establishing New Jersey-India Commission New Jersey Governor Phil Murphy took a significant step towards fostering stronger cultural and economic ties with India by signing an executive order to establish the New Jersey-India Commission. The announcement was made during a press conference where Governor Murphy addressed two distinct but impactful topics - the solemn lowering of flags in honor of Sergeant William Rivers, a local hero, and the exciting news of New Jersey hosting the final match of the 2026 World Cup. Amidst these updates, Governor Murphy highlighted the historic moment of marking a new chapter in the friendship between New Jersey and the Republic of India. Honoring Sergeant William Rivers: The Governor commenced the conference by expressing condolences to the family of Sergeant William Rivers, a native of Willingboro and a member of the

President Trump Rally in North Charleston, South Carolina, on Wednesday, February 14, 2024

  Donald Trump "President Donald J. Trump Energizes Supporters at Get Out the Vote Rally in North Charleston, S.C. Ahead of South Carolina GOP Primary" On the eve of Valentine's Day, former President Donald J. Trump, the 45th President of the United States, took center stage at the Charleston Area Convention Center in North Charleston, South Carolina, for a spirited Get Out the Vote Rally on February 14, 2024. The event, strategically timed ahead of the upcoming South Carolina GOP Primary on February 24, aimed to mobilize and rally supporters for a strong showing in the state.

JUST IN: Nikki Haley Reacts To Trump's Endorsement Of A New RNC Chair And Lara Trump As Co-Chair

  Photo credit: Gage Skidmore/CC BY-SA 2.0,  via Flickr Trump's RNC Shake-Up Sparks Controversy: Nikki Haley's Candid Response and Concerns Over Party Direction In a surprising turn of events, former Governor Nikki Haley (R-SC) shared her candid thoughts during a campaign event in Bamberg, SC, addressing former President Donald Trump's recent endorsement of Michael Whatley for RNC Chair and Lara Trump as Co-Chair. Haley's remarks shed light on the tumultuous dynamics within the Republican Party and raised questions about the party's future. Haley began by recounting Trump's earlier attempt to secure the RNC's nomination without a formal vote, emphasizing the importance of allowing South Carolinians and citizens across the nation the right to participate in the democratic process. According to Haley, Trump's initial approach, seeking a presumptive nomination, faced backlash, leading him to reconsider.

Kamala Harris Tweet Called Out By GOP Lawmaker Decrying Insurrection Accusations Against Trump

  Photo "Donald Trump" by  Dan Scavino GOP Lawmaker Cory Mills Challenges Kamala Harris Tweet Amidst Trump Insurrection Accusations At a recent House Republican press briefing aimed at endorsing a resolution declaring that former President Donald Trump did not incite an insurrection, Rep. Cory Mills (R-FL) took the opportunity to call out then-Sen. Kamala Harris (D-CA) for her role in promoting a bail fund during the tumultuous events of 2020. Mills began by expressing his gratitude and proceeded to make a series of pointed statements, addressing what he perceived as a double standard in assessing actions that could be construed as inciting violence. The Florida lawmaker drew attention to Kamala Harris's fundraising efforts for a bail fund, suggesting that she was supporting individuals involved in destructive activities during the 2020 unrest. "Let's talk about inciting violence and promoting an insurrection," Mills asserted. He urged a closer examination o